- M&A Mindset
- Posts
- Why The Highest Offer Isn't Always The Best Deal
Why The Highest Offer Isn't Always The Best Deal
Plus: How Buyers Compare Deals (When They Have Multiple Options)

Quick M&A Insights, Infographics, & Interesting Info Every Week!
Welcome to the M&A Mindset!
This Week:
This week we’re focusing on how deals get evaluated and why the “best” offer isn’t always the one that wins.
First, why the highest offer isn’t always the best deal. Price gets the attention, but structure, certainty, and fit ultimately determine what a seller actually receives.
Then, how buyers compare deals when they have multiple opportunities. What stands out, what gets discounted, and how decisions get made when it’s not just about one business.
Plus, as always: curated articles, practical learning resources, M&A merch, and something to lighten things up at the end.
Let’s dive in.
– Derek
Table of Contents
INTERESTING INFOGRAPHIC
Each week, I feature a visually engaging infographic that distills a key M&A subject area into an easy-to-digest format. These quick reference guides aim to deliver clarity, insight, and practical understanding at a glance.
Why The Highest Offer Isn’t Always The Best Deal
M&A TOPIC BRIEFING
In this section, I provide a clear, concise overview of a specific topic, trend, or concept within the realm of M&A. The goal is to educate, inform, and spark discussions on relevant subjects, helping you deepen your knowledge and better navigate the complexities of M&A more confidently.
How Buyers Compare Deals
(When They Have Multiple Options)
10 AI Stocks to Lead the Next Decade
AI isn’t a tech trend – it’s a full-blown, multi-trillion dollar race, and 10 companies are already pulling ahead.
These are the innovators driving real revenue, attracting institutional attention, and positioning for massive growth.
Get all 10 tickers in The 10 Best AI Stocks to Own in 2026, free today.
ARTICLES OF INTEREST

Buyers Are Hungry for Quality Business in Q1 2026 - This report shows a stabilizing but active small-business M&A market, with growing buyer demand (including more sophisticated and well-capitalized buyers), rising seller participation driven by retirements, and strong interest concentrated in profitable, scalable businesses.
How Strategic M&A Benefits Owner-Operators - Strategic M&A can accelerate growth beyond what organic efforts alone can achieve, allowing owner-operators to quickly add capabilities, customers, or markets.
M&A Capability for a New Era: Five Ways AI Is Creating More Value in M&A Right Now - Leading acquirers are building end-to-end M&A capabilities enhanced by AI, which is transforming dealmaking by improving target identification, accelerating diligence, and increasing synergy precision.
What Emotions Get In The Way When Selling Your Business - Emotions like ego, fear, attachment, and impatience can distort decision-making during a sale, often causing owners to overvalue their business, resist reasonable deal terms, or delay decisions.
How To Create An Exit Strategy For Your Business - An effective exit strategy requires early planning, understanding potential buyers, and building a business that can operate independently, so owners can maximize value and transition smoothly when the time comes.
EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES

Master Financial Modeling from Elite Practitioners
6 jam-packed courses with countless cases and 30+ exercises to help you learn financial modeling. Each course is designed to guide you step-by-step in your journey to develop elite modeling skills. Click Here!
FROM THE BENCHMARK BLOG
My firm, Benchmark International, a global, award-winning sell-side M&A company, has a ton of great resources that help anyone considering selling or buying a business get more educated on all aspects of the process. Below is just one helpful article. Check out Benchmark International for many more useful articles, news, and resources.
INDUSTRY ASSOCIATIONS

Trade Associations in the M&A Industry
FRIENDS OF THE M&A MINDSET
From time to time, we’ll highlight newsletters and podcasts we genuinely read, listen to, and respect across M&A, PE, and the broader deal ecosystem.
No paid placements. No mass promotions. Just thoughtful, high-quality content that complements the M&A Mindset.
Here’s a few newsletters that I’ve signed up for and found interesting. Thought you might enjoy checking them out.
Have something to suggest that we should know about? Reach out.
Are you running your business on incomplete numbers?
Most business owners have financials. Few have financial clarity. BELAY's outsourced accounting team manages your books, tracks key metrics, and delivers timely reporting so you always know where your business stands — and what to do next.
LIGHTEN UP!
In the fast-paced world of M&A, we can sometimes take things (and ourselves) a bit too seriously, so it’s good to remember to enjoy a lighter moment now and then.
Welcome To Wall Street: 5 Career Vets Share Their Craziest Memories
M&A MERCH
Here’s a find for us finance folks to grab some M&A-inspired swag. Stuff for those of us that speak fluent EBITDA. If you find others that have great deal-themed gear, send them this way so we can let everyone know. Enjoy!
RATE THIS WEEK'S ISSUEWhat did you think? |
Thanks for reading this week's edition!
Share the M&A Mindset with colleagues who'd benefit from straightforward M&A insights.
Got a topic you want covered or feedback to share? Just hit reply—I read everything.
Stay Curious,
Derek Avdul
New to the M&A Mindset? This weekly newsletter cuts through the noise with concise insights, infographics, and resources on middle-market M&A—trusted by 5,500+ deal professionals, business owners, and investors. Whether you're planning a transaction, building your expertise, or just fascinated by deals, you'll find something valuable here every week.
Questions or suggestions? [email protected]





















Reply